Direct contact to law firm
Berlin +49 30 88 03 59 0
Poznań / Warszawa +48 61 85 82 55 0
Berlin berlin@vonzanthier.com
Poznań / Warszawa poznan@vonzanthier.com
VON ZANTHIER & DACHOWSKI
Current articles
 

Investments in renewable energy sources NON-MARKET REDISPATCH – A STABILISATION MECHANISM OR A ROOM FOR ABUSE?

In recent times, the issue of non-market redispatch of electricity from renewable energy sources (RES) has become one of the main challenges facing the Polish energy sector. This problem significantly affects the profitability and development of the RES sector, causing considerable financial losses for energy producers.

Nature of redispatch

Non-market redispatch refers to the intervention of the transmission system operator – in Poland, Polskie Sieci Elektroenergetyczne S.A. (PSE) – involving changes to the production schedules of generating units outside of market mechanisms, in order to ensure the safe operation of the power system. In simple terms, PSE instructs producers to limit energy generation not because of market signals, but because the grid cannot safely absorb the electricity.

In practice, however, these actions are often carried out without clearly defined criteria that would guarantee equal treatment of energy producers and prevent discrimination.

Legal situation

The legal grounds for curtailing RES installations raise serious concerns.

In the Polish legal system, generating units have no real ability to negotiate reliability terms—these clauses are imposed unilaterally in grid connection agreements. This structure contradicts the intent of EU regulations, which foresee such clauses as voluntary. As a result, RES producers lose the right to compensation for forced production curtailments.

Another controversial aspect is the selection criteria for which units are curtailed—large photovoltaic farms, in particular, are affected far more frequently than others.

There are relatively simple and low-cost changes that could improve the situation for RES producers. Most importantly, the regulations that prevent grid connection agreements from including guaranteed levels of supply reliability must be amended—currently, the lack of such provisions disproportionately burdens producers of solar and wind energy, whose installations are most frequently curtailed.

Equally important is the simplification of procedures and the method of calculating compensation. Current mechanisms are complex and often opaque.

Possibility of seeking compensation

In each individual case, energy producers should consider legal actions that may allow them to fully recover their losses.

When it comes to redispatch, the following should be examined:

• Was the curtailment of the plant necessary in that particular instance? According to EU law, redispatch may only be used under strictly defined conditions, as a last resort and in a proportionate manner. In practice, however, it has become a nearly routine network management tool.

• Was the principle of non-discrimination respected? Photovoltaic installations are curtailed much more frequently than wind sources, raising questions about the transparency and objectivity of the criteria used.

• Did PSE correctly calculate the amount of compensation in accordance with EU law?

• Did the producer voluntarily sign a grid connection agreement that does not guarantee reliable supply?

A negative answer to even one of these questions should prompt a review of potential compensation claims.

Conclusion

To effectively address the challenges of non-market redispatch, energy producers must understand their legal position and actively pursue the protection of their interests.

The issues outlined above paint a picture in which the costs of non-market redispatch are borne entirely by RES producers. Increasingly, there is legal basis for seeking compensation for unjustified curtailments. This is not just a matter of individual claims—it is also part of a broader transformation that should lead to greater recognition of the interests of all market participants in the energy sector.

Share this article

You may also be interested in these articles:

current, Investments in renewable energies
10.11.2026

From Due Diligence to Closing – how to safely buy and sell wind projects in Poland

In transactions involving wind projects, the purchase price is only one element of the project’s value. Equally important are the land rights, the quality of administrative decisions, the grid connection status, the completeness of the documentation and the allocation of risk if the project does not reach the expected stage of development.

Read article
current, Investments in renewable energies
30.10.2026

Permits Without Surprises – Spatial Planning, Environmental Decisions and Cooperation with Municipalities

The success of a wind energy project depends not only on finding a suitable location and securing financing. It is also crucial to coordinate spatial planning, environmental procedures and cooperation with the municipality from the outset. If these processes are not aligned, the project may face delays, additional costs and changes to its plans. In this article, we explain what investors in Poland should consider and how to identify permitting risks at an early stage.

Read article
current
22.10.2026

Quo vadis, Polish-German relations? On trust, tensions and a shared future

On 15 October 2026, VON ZANTHIER & DACHOWSKI hosted the conference “Quo vadis, Polish-German relations?” in Poznań. Participants from Poland, Germany and other countries discussed the history of relations between the two countries, their current state and what the future may hold.

Read article